My Neighbor Didn’t Show Her Child to Anyone for Three Years

Martha had always found something unsettling about her neighbor Nelly. In three years, she rarely saw Nelly outside, and the absence of her supposed baby raised alarms. When Martha finally worked up the courage to speak to her, Nelly’s fear-driven retreat only deepened the mystery.

Concerned, Martha shared her unease with her husband, Evan, but he brushed it off. “Not everyone is social,” he said, encouraging her to focus on their family. Yet Martha couldn’t shake her suspicions, especially after Mrs. Freddie, another neighbor, vowed to investigate.

Mrs. Freddie’s attempt to deliver a pie to Nelly ended in rejection, further solidifying Martha’s belief that something was amiss. Days later, while sorting mail, Martha discovered a letter meant for Nelly, prompting her to approach Nelly’s house. As she peered through the window, her heart raced—she spotted a little boy with a familiar birthmark. Sh0cked, Martha collapsed on the porch.

When she regained consciousness, the neighbors surrounded her, concern etched on their faces. After regaining her composure, Martha demanded answers from Nelly. The confrontation revealed a painful truth: Nelly’s son, Tommy, was Evan’s child, conceived during a brief affair. Nelly had been coerced into hiding, living next door under the guise of a new life.

As Martha grappled with the betrayal, she wrestled with a flood of emotions. How could Evan have lied for so long? In the following days, she went through the motions, but the knowledge of her husband’s deceit gnawed at her.

Continue reading…