That Thanksgiving morning, the house felt wrong—too polished, too still, as if it was waiting for something that would never come. I made coffee out of habit, hearing Marla’s voice in my mind: Stick to a routine. It’ll help you get your feet back under you.
I grabbed the brown jacket Sarah had given me years ago and stepped outside, just to feel the cold. I walked to the grocery store and bought food I didn’t need—rotisserie chicken, rolls, cranberry sauce, pumpkin pie. I told myself it was for a proper dinner, though I knew I wouldn’t eat any of it.
A woman sat under a bare maple tree near the cart return. No coat. Hands trembling. Eyes fixed on the concrete. People walked past, pretending not to notice. Something inside me tightened.
Marla’s voice nudged me: Do something good, honey.
I approached slowly. She tensed.
“I’m not here to bother you,” I said softly. “You just look cold.”
Her eyes flicked up—tired, wary. I slipped off my jacket and held it out.
“You need this more than I do.”
She didn’t thank me at first. She just clutched the jacket like it might disappear. I handed her a grocery bag, scribbled my address on the pie box, and murmured, “If you need help, I’m Eric.”
A tiny whispered thank you and I walked away. That night, I lied to Sarah over video, pretending I’d eaten a proper meal. But I couldn’t stop wondering—was she warm? Did she have somewhere safe to go? Eventually, I told myself I had done enough.
I hadn’t forgotten her. I had just tucked the memory into quiet corners of my heart. Then, one Thanksgiving afternoon, the doorbell rang.
Sarah and her husband were arguing over board games and cocoa when I opened the door.
It was her. Healthier, hair brushed, cheeks flushed from the cold. She held a small black backpack to her chest.
“I hoped you still lived here,” she said softly.
I stepped aside. She placed the backpack in my hands. Inside, folded neatly, was my brown jacket. On top sat a small wooden box.
I opened it. A gold-faced wristwatch rested inside, along with a folded check: $20,000.
“I can’t take this,” I stammered. “I don’t even know you.”
Charlotte told us everything. Her husband, Levi—charming at first, thContinue reading…