My lawyer, a fierce woman named Ms. Darden, stood up.
“Your Honor,” she said quietly. “We can tell you stories all day. But we prefer to show you the truth.”
Daniel smirked. He whispered something to his mother. Agnes giggled.
Witness 2: Mr. Grayson.
The neighbor hobbled to the stand. He was eighty years old.
“I heard the screaming,” he said, his voice shaking. “I looked out. I saw Daniel swinging that stick like he was chopping wood. And I saw his parents… they were smiling. Like they were watching a TV show.”
“Objection!” Sterling shouted. “Speculation!”
“Overruled,” Judge Holt said, staring at Agnes.
The Turning Point.
It was time for the digital evidence.
Ms. Darden plugged in her laptop. “Your Honor, the defense claims this was a momentary lapse of judgment in self-defense. We have evidence that proves premeditated malice.”
The screens in the courtroom flickered to life.
First, the video from Mr. Grayson’s porch. The audio was grainy, but undeniable.
“Get up and make breakfast!”
The sickening thud.
Agnes’s voice: “Serves her right.”
The courtroom went deadly silent. Daniel’s smirk vanished.
She projected the messages onto the wall.
Agnes (Text to Daniel – 2 weeks prior): She’s getting too mouthy. You need to remind her who pays the mortgage. Don’t be afraid to be firm.
Daniel (Response): I will. I’m waiting for the right moment. If she loses the brat, we can try again with a surrogate who isn’t so weak.
Victor (Text): Make sure there are no marks on the face. The body heals. The face shows.
A collective gasp swept through the room. The jury looked horrified. Even the court reporter stopped typing for a second.
This wasn’t abuse. This was a hunting party.
Daniel’s face drained of all color. He looked at his lawyer, who was currently rubbing his temples, realizing his case was dead.
“Sit down, Mrs. Mercer!” Judge Holt barked. “One more outburst and you will be held in contempt.”
Ms. Darden looked at the judge. “We also have a letter from Sarah’s OB-GYN.” Continue reading…